I bought a rusty set of these on the cheap, wasn't really expecting too much from them, but I have been bitten by the vintage iron bug and when I see plates that are in the Iron Guide out in the wild, I tend to want to get them.
What I will say is that after I cleaned these up (oxalic acid bath and a lot of scrubbing, nothing super fancy), and added ivory colored paint to the lettering, these are one of the most nicely cast plates I have. The lettering and detail is phenomenal.
They do have one weird feature. The hub protrudes more than the rim, so there are gaps between them when they're sitting on a bar. This is a mixed bag. It irks me, but also it makes it super easy to grab them.
Performance
Value
Build Quality