Marcy Vintage Weight Plates

Marcy Vintage Weight Plates

Classic West Coast deep-dish weights, produced by Dr. Walter Marcyan during the golden era, are known for their distinctive deep mold, thick rims, and hubs that create a unique look. The timeless proportions of the markings and design extend down to the smallest change plates, all featuring the same iconic style.

Check Price
To follow equipment, you must be logged in.

Marcy Vintage Weight Plates Reviews

Based on 10 reviews from Gym Radar users, the Marcy Marcy Vintage Weight Plates have an average rating of 4.07 out of 5. They're currently the #33 most-owned Iron on Gym Radar, with 11 home gyms reporting ownership.

10 Reviews

4.07 / 5
Performance
4.40 / 5
Build Quality
3.40 / 5
Value
4.40 / 5

User Reviews

Leave a Review
user profile
Achievement badge
Bigchrisringo
The Panther Pit
73 reviews
1077 points
(3.67)
6/27/2026
Simply beautiful plates. Incredibly inaccurate but nonetheless they look amazing. Picked up two pairs of 45’s on marketplace for only 50$🤯 I managed to find a close enough pair out of the group. Good for hub lifting and bench or squat. Don’t recommend deadlift as they’re fragile. Plan to sell the other pair I don’t need or trade them at some point. But for now I’m pleased letting them live in my gym.
Performance
Value
Build Quality

user profile
Achievement badge
Montana
Iron Fish Barbell
121 reviews
1351 points
(3.33)
6/25/2026
Marcy deep dish are beautiful, unique, vintage, etc. What they are also known for is being innacurate, imperfect castings, and cracking. My 45s are 42.5lbs and 47.5lbs. I had to add a ton of magnets to make my light 45 accurate. They are fantastic for hub lifting though. Probably great for everything else when actually accurate. Accurate plates are harder to find. Especially 45s.
Performance
Value
Build Quality

user profile
Achievement badge
Big Grant
Scouts Honor
22 reviews
315 points
(4.33)
6/20/2026
Classic design and classic feel. These have such a deep lip they are super easy to carry. Some of my 45s are showing signs of cracking around the hub which is very common on the 45s. One of them is so cracked it will be retired and thrown on display. The 25s really are the crown jewel of this set with having the same design and being deepdish like the 45s, just something about them feels so good. Time to collect the rest of the set and training hub lifting on them!
Performance
Value
Build Quality

user profile
Achievement badge
Big Hockey Dave
Hatz Strength Club
107 reviews
1331 points
(4.33)
6/16/2026
Marcy deep dish 45s have a distinctive look and a great West Coast Muscle Beach vibe. I love the character of these plates, and the hub design makes them fun for hub lifting too. The downsides are that they can be inaccurate, and they have a reputation for cracking around the hub, so condition matters.
Performance
Value
Build Quality

user profile
Achievement badge
Carney Gym
Carney Gym
35 reviews
613 points
(4.00)
6/14/2026
First plates I hub lifted. Height/size of the hub make it a perfect beginner plate. Best looking deep dish 25s (and 10s) in my opinion. However, they have their flaws... I have to take it easy on them or risk cracking a hub. And I had to add 3lb of Rob's Vintage Gainz magnetic weights to one of my 45s to equal the heavier one.
Performance
Value
Build Quality

user profile
Achievement badge
Big Ben Wyko
Wykos Gym
108 reviews
1287 points
(4.00)
5/4/2026
They look cool. However the weight of my plates are way off. One is 42 the other is 45. They are known to crack around the hub. Cool for hub lifting.
Performance
Value
Build Quality

user profile
Achievement badge
ATP Gym
ATP Gym
581 reviews
4074 points
(3.67)
4/1/2026
The Marcy Vintage Weight Plates are iconic "Golden Era" pieces designed by Dr. Walter Marcyan. They are highly sought after by collectors for their classic West Coast aesthetic, characterized by a deep dish mold, thick rims, and distinctive "whiskers" (spokes) that appear on all sizes, including the smallest change plates
Performance
Value
Build Quality

user profile
Achievement badge
Medium Sized Craig
The Gravity War Tactical Operations Center
104 reviews
1341 points
(4.00)
3/28/2026
These weights are not the most accurate in the world (I have a 43 and 46lbs set), actually not complaining about that since I wanted them for hub lifting, and now I have a baby 45 to work up to the full one. I think the whiskers look cool and three plates are one of the best looking in my small vintage weight collection.
Performance
Value
Build Quality

user profile
Achievement badge
The Dark Lord
House of Pain
125 reviews
1448 points
(4.33)
3/23/2026
not the most accurate of plates, but they are desirable as vintage deep dish collectors pieces. If you get a chance to purchase some, ask the seller for accurate weight of each plate to see if the set you're getting is balanced, or how far off from the labeled weight each plate might be so that you know if they are going to be useful to you.
Performance
Value
Build Quality

user profile
Achievement badge
Maffew Wallrus
Maffew Wallrus's Gym
54 reviews
932 points
(5.00)
3/6/2026
Some of my favorite looking plates. Vintage Weights PGH points of that these plates are rare in the fact that the “spokes” (he calls them whiskers) are on every plate all the way down to the 2.5s…which I don’t have…yet. Deep rim, tall hub and crisp lettering.
Performance
Value
Build Quality

Official Massenomics Review

Gyms With This Marcy Vintage Weight Plates

Loading gyms with this piece...

Other Pieces Like This

Loading similar pieces...

More From Marcy

Loading more pieces from Marcy...