I've had most of my set (in terms of the number of plates) for over a month at the time of this review. Overall, I think these are great bumpers. The lip on the edge makes them super easy to move. They are much thinner than my previous crumb bumpers (the 45s are about an inch thinner), and they have a really cool look to them. I did get a good deal on the 460lb set when I purchased it, but I had to send back most of my 45s twice unfortunately. The first round had 6 out of 8 bumpers have significant QA issues, like divots or even cuts into the bumper. I sent them back. The second set had to have 4 out of the 6 sent back because of issues as well. Finally, on the last round, I have my complete set of 8 45s and the 10s, 15s, and 25s pairs. Fringe was easy to work with on the returns, but it was frustrating that I had to send back plates during a second go-around. Maybe I was being too picky on a few of them, but you still have to send back a pair even if only one has issues. Because of these issues, I did have to reduce the ratings, but I still like the plates overall. When they come as they should, they are great plates.
Performance
Value
Build Quality