I own vintage milled Yorks, Rogue Deep Dish, and generic plates. These are my second favorite plates behind the vintage Yorks and are excellent. The weight is precise, they are easy to put on the bar due to the well-designed lip, and are smooth but with enough friction on the backside so you can still remove them. The tolerances on these are TIGHT. I think the price is fair but not a bargain. Definitely a welcome addition to my home gym and a plate I would highly recommend. They have an old school feel and look and will last a lifetime.
Performance
Value
Build Quality