Phenomenal plates. I hemmed and hawed for a while as to whether to upgrade my CAP plates at all, and if so for Strength Co, Rogue deep dish, used calibrated or something else?
What sold me on the milled Yorks was the price (half of those new plates), accuracy, availability (varies of course), the 45 face design, and the gestalt of them given York's history and the manual finish on them.
I prefer the asymmetrical face on these to the TSC, and I do like the "2-1/2" versus "2.5 lbs". Fractions just feel right with imperial units. The filleted lip is super comfortable and the milling gives you extra grip while looking killer. They are hand finished (milling patterns are unique to every single plate) and literally a little rough around the edges, and the center holes aren't exactly centered. I'll never sell them.
Performance
Value
Build Quality