These are controversial because they are SO good. I hated adjustable dumbbells until I tried these. The knurling is better than most if not all dumbbells I have ever used. The competitors have passive knurling that is usually rubber or plastic. These also feel much more balanced- other adjustable dumbbells like the NuoBells and Trulaps are so long- like super unwieldy. These are much more compact.
They are very durable- you could throw them around no issue. I don’t typically throw or drop my weights, but if you get in a spot where you need to you don’t have to worry about an accident, which is probably the case and point for me.
The change system and the adder plates are probably where these get knocked by others but I think the good far outweighs the bad here. You have to add the 2.5lb plates by hand, but I have never worried about them falling out. Yes, it rattles when they are in if you are doing something like lateral raises. Also, the change system is fast- I will say it’s hard to tell which weight you are selecting initially, but you start to get it once you use them. Also you have to dial in the cradle width to make sure it’s possible to rerack every time with no issues like ever. But it does require patience and is a pain to dial in initially but once it’s set you’re golden…until you upgrade another 20lbs like I did and have to do it again lol. 125lbs is overkill, but 105lbs is my sweet spot right now and what I have. It’s cool that you can upgrade over time.
These are ridiculously expensive. Like I would never tell my friends that aren’t in this space that I spent this much on a pair of dumbbells. But they are the best out there in my opinion. And I sold my set of 5-45lb fixed dumbbells for the same price I bought these for initially ($900 - 85lb set) and these take up significantly less space and have a much larger range.
Performance
Value
Build Quality