The Dark Lord's Reviews (125)


(5.00)
3/12/2026
This bench is an absolute workhorse in my gym. Used with almost every workout. No wobble at all when mounted in the incline position and absolutely rock solid when flat. Someday I hope to get a fixed bench press but until then this works great inside my rack. I have benched 375 on this with no issues at all.
Performance
Value
Build Quality

(3.00)
3/11/2026
these are of course iconic because of the image of Arnold and will likely be collectors items someday far in the future. For current every day use, they fall short of expectations. They lack the same cachet as a York deep dish or other more vintage deep dish iron, and just don't clang with the sound of history when pushed together. If you're shopping for them on the secondary market, most that I've seen are currently overpriced. As far as build quality, the rim feels kind of thin and I worry about chipping in the long run if a plate were dropped. The same goes for the hub and I most definitely would never do dead lifts with these plates. The finish is rather slick, so even hub lifting isn't that great with these. After using them a few times for bench press, mine have now largely been relegated to wall hangers.
Performance
Value
Build Quality

(4.00)
3/11/2026
They are technically vintage and are considered collectible, but they are quite common so the prices are not bad at all. A decent pair typically goes for around $100. They are heavy and very sturdy. Unlike the shipwheel collars that seem to snap a hub off if you look at them sideways, these bastards could get left in San Quinton for 5 years and would emerge looking deadly and ripped, with two new bachelors degrees and a tear drop tattoo.
Performance
Value
Build Quality

(4.33)
3/11/2026
Popular deep dish vintage weights with a really cool Eagle Head design. They are definitely collectible and popular, but there are enough of them floating around that the prices aren't too outrageous (yet). They were released in the 1980s with a black, gray or blue finish. They can be obtained on the secondary collectors market for around $400-500 for a pair of 45s, or you can hunt your local FMP relentlessly and try to snag a pair from a widow who doesn't know what they are. Good luck!
Performance
Value
Build Quality

(3.33)
3/11/2026
These are highly desirable collectible collars from York. There were multiple generations made between the 1930s and 1950s, possibly into the 60s. Each generation has slight differences in hub shape and length, cylinder height, and the size or configuration of the wing nuts. The Iron Guide has good illustrative images and descriptions for each version. These tend to be quite pricey for an intact pair in decent shape, typically at least $1000 if functional and clean; so if you see some at a garage sale, don't pass them up!
Performance
Value
Build Quality

(4.33)
3/11/2026
Iron Man weights were created by Peary Rader, the publisher of Iron Man Magazine for decades. Rader was a pillar of the powerlifting and bodybuilding world from the late 1930s through the 80s. He was an absolute icon of the Physical Culture world. He made plates in Olympic style that weighed 100lb and 50lb, as well as standard 1" plates in a full array of sizes from 1 1/4 lb to 50 lb. As vintage plates go, the 2" bore plates are sought after and correspondingly expensive, running $1500-2000 for a pair of 100s. The 1" plates are also very collectible but, being much more common, are quite accessibly priced and more readily available on the secondary collectors market. The 100s and 50s tend to run heavier than face value, which is pretty common for old vintage iron plates.
Performance
Value
Build Quality

(5.00)
3/11/2026
Highly accurate milled era York plates that were custom made for the weight room at the US Naval Academy in Annapolis, MD. In the spirit of the eternal Army/Navy rivalry, the navy blue plates are emblazoned with a bright yellow BEAT ARMY. As a navy veteran, I absolutely had to own a pair... and then wound up getting the full set, all in original navy blue paint. The change plates for this set are the same as the regular York milled change plates, they're just painted in the same blue as the 45s.
Performance
Value
Build Quality

(5.00)
3/11/2026
The pinnacle of vintage weight plate collecting. These are the most famous and sought after plates, not only for their amazing design but for the mind-blowing history that accompanies these plates. They aren't the oldest but they are the most recognizable and unique plates, plus the antics of the crew that used them are legendary. They were featured in the late 1960s and early 70s at the famous golden era powerlifting mecca, Zuver's Hall of Fame Gym in Costa Mesa, CA. They were used prominently in the very first ever World's Strongest Man competition in 1977. These plates feature a MASSIVELY muscled man, painted gold, spread-eagled as if he were pushing the rims away. If DaVinci had been a weightlifter, this is what his Vitruvian man would have looked like. The plates were made in 50 lb, 100 lb, 150 lb, and 200 lb sizes.
Performance
Value
Build Quality

125 total